Unilever slams Ben & Jerry’s lawsuit

Unilever slams Ben & Jerry’s lawsuit

Unilever slams Ben & Jerry’s lawsuit (19459000)

The article was updated in order to remove a false statement that B&J’s advocacy for social missions is limited to packaging.

  • Unilever claims B&J’s can’t sue its parent
  • Magnum offered David Stever a new position as CEO, but he chose to resign.
  • B&J directors are not allowed to advocate for any cause.
  • Unilever barred from US State agency contracts due to political controversy caused by B&J

Unilever has completed its operational demerger for its ice-cream division (July 1st, 2025), however legal disputes with one of the company’s top food brands have investors thinking.

Ben & Jerry wants to alleviate investor fears about the Magnum Ice Cream Company – as this newly formed entity will be called – by having the New York District Court dismiss the revised Ben & Jerry complaint.

Unilever claims in a motion for dismissal that Ben & Jerry (B&J)’s directors are not allowed to sue their parent company, or make public statements about ‘controversial topics and divisions’.

Anuradha Mitchelltal, B&J’s chairman is also accused by the multinational of directing B&J to focus’recklessly’ on the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict to the detriment to its wider business.

Unilever’s motion gives a good idea of how it views B&J’s accusations and shows the split between them at this crucial time in their relationship.

Unilever has made a number of key accusations and rebukes. . .

B&J directors cannot sue

Unilever has issued a statement that is a strong rebuke to B&J. It claims directors are only allowed ‘limited’ rights in relation to the social mission of the brand, but they lack the legal authority. The motion states that by law and contract, they “are not B&J and do not have control over B&J and therefore cannot sue like B&J”.

Unilever also tries to dispel B&J’s claim that the brand was’muzzled.’ They say that B&J’s Mittal has ‘unilaterally issued’ statements to the media despite contract restrictions.

Unilever caught in crossfire between Israel and Palestine

Unilever explains ‘the chaos’ that followed B&J’s decision to withdraw from the West Bank. B&J’s leadership announced in 2021 that it would cease selling ice-cream in settlement areas, but Unilever sold the IP rights of the B&J brand to a distributor to allow the company to carry on trading in 2022. B&J sued Unilever for alleged overreach, but both sides reached an out-of-court settlement.

Unilever, on the other hand, is not ‘over’ yet.

The group claims that it is still blacklisted by at least nine US states which have anti-BDS legislation. Unilever has been prevented from entering into contracts with local and state governments, and its stock was divested.

Unilever says Indonesia also issued a fatwa that covers the whole portfolio of its group, meaning consumers have been urged to boycott Unilever’s products because they perceive them as being in solidarity with Israel.

Unilever claims that B&J directors “selected to recklessly concentrate on the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict, taking a strongly pro-Palestinian and anti-Israel position and thus embroiling B&J & Unilever into one of the most divisive issues of our times.”

The current dispute has its roots in the [B&J directors’] Unilever and B&J, global brands sold in over 190 countries, have suffered a negative impact because of their decision to dive into controversial issues, such as the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, that has caused protests, boycotts and political unrest around the world.

B&J’s advocacy is limited in scope

Ben & Jerry’s has repeatedly claimed that Unilever had stopped it from expressing its views on political and social issues, which was in violation of Unilever’s social mission.

The CPG giant claims that the advocacy of brand directors is restricted. Unilever says that the merger agreement does not allow Class I Directors to issue any statements in B&J’s name. In the contract, certain initiatives are identified, including eco-friendly ingredients and packaging, as well as social mission causes.

But nothing…permits you to? [directors] To engage in social activism and to issue public statements, whether on social media or other platforms, on any subject it chooses, regardless of what the implications are for B&J or Unilever.”

Unilever has blocked donations to charities that are deemed controversial

Ben & Jerry’s can make suggestions to Unilever about charities that Unilever could support.

The CPG company refused to support B&J because it feared a political backlash.

This ice-cream company suggested that the Institute for Middle East Understanding, the United Nations Special Rapporteur and Jewish Voice for Peace receive the gift in 2023. In 2024 they proposed to give the money to the Council on American-Islamic Relations and Jewish Voice for Peace.

Unilever, however, deemed these organizations “controversial” and declined to comply.

In its motion for dismissal, the company states that it did not wish to be seen as again taking sides in the Gaza conflict and/or associating with groups who made divisive remarks about Israel and/or supported Hamas’s attack against Israel and their abduction of hostsages. This would have risked reigniting its previous backlash.

What are the directors of Ben & Jerry?

The class I directors involved in this lawsuit include:

  • Anuradha Mittal
  • Daryn Dodson
  • Jennifer Henderson
  • Detavio Sams
  • Chivy Sok

Magnum CEO to play a ‘prominent’ role

David Stever has been announced as Ben & Jerry’s CEO for May 2023.

B&J claimed earlier this year that Unilever was trying to remove its CEO David Stever because he supported the social mission statement of their brand. Unilever set a ‘four-day deadline arbitrarily’ to the B&J board to decide on the future of the CEO and ‘failed’ to communicate with the brand in good faith about the restructuring.

Unilever has issued a sharp rebuke for Mittal’s alleged failure to inform the media that he would be fired despite knowing that Stever was being reviewed as part of an overall review of leadership in the Ice Cream Division.

“[The] Unilever’s motion for dismissal states that the new Stever allegations are “clearly false” and the claim they made about the possible future of the Spin-Off in relation to the Spin-Off was not ready.

Unilever informed the Class I directors that they were re-evaluating Stever’s future as CEO along with most of its leaders in the ice cream sector, due to the Spin Off, and not the social mission.

Stever was offered a larger role within the global ice-cream business by Unilever, along with a higher salary to match the increased job scope. Stever declined this role, and instead chose to resign from B&J.

Weil Gotshal & Manges LLP is the law firm representing Unilever. Ben & Jerry’s is represented by Ahmad, Zavitsanos & Mensing PLLC.

View Article Source

Share Article
Facebook
LinkedIn
X
Ascot marketing agency says small businesses can win Black Friday week without cutting prices
Harley Street-trained psychotherapist moves his practice to Poland to treat British expats online
DoorDash to buy Instacart in $17bn deal, its largest takeover to date
Secret Link