All of us have experienced this. You know that familiar knot when you are about to show your work on social media, whether it’s with a client or a co-worker. You hear the voice saying that others have it all figured out while you are just trying to wing it. You’re sure that you will be exposed as a scam sooner or later.
You’re not alone if any of these things sound familiar. It’s so widespread, that they named it. Imposter Syndrome doesn’t only affect newbies: even seasoned CEOs and creative directors can fall victim to it. The uninvited critic at each brainstorming meeting, it’s always there. The good news is that it can be controlled.
We asked our creative community members to share the most successful strategies they use for quieting their inner critic. The results were not a single solution that fits all, but a collection of tools and practical strategies. You can find their full discussions here or here. Not yet joined The Studio? Join The Studio now – it’s FREE!
Shared experience is powerful.
The relief of realizing that imposter’s syndrome is universal was a common theme. Marcus Marritt, illustrator and art director, describes the moment he had a lightbulb: “For me, it just clicked one day; appreciating how imposter syndrome is such a shared experience. If we’re all feeling this way, then surely there are no impostors!”
Marcus views the imposter’s syndrome now as an inherent part of creative processes. “Being my own worst critic, feeling like an imposter, has me wanting to improve the craft,” He explains. He recommends that you try to find a way out if it is bringing your down. “stepping back and looking over all the work from all the years, and appreciating and being grateful for what you have done. You made that happen. No one else. So who’s the imposter?”
Neil Richards is a digital designer who echoes this sentiment and says: “There’s also a great camaraderie in British self-deprecation… so in a way ‘imposter syndrome’ is a positive thing. It keeps you in check and most likely improves your work.”
The imposter syndrome is often a result of comparing oneself unfavourably with others. But it’s often because you do not know the person. Richard Longmuir, creative director at a major agency in London, found meeting industry peers and figures that he respected was a huge game changer. “Either you find out that they are super-nice and experience the same imposter syndrome you do, or you realise they’re faking it and it’s all a front,” He says “Which makes you think: ‘Oh well, maybe I can do this’.”
Effective strategies for practical living
Our community has also provided some specific tips for dealing with imposter’s syndrome in the day to day. Iancu Barbarasa, a graphic designer and an illustrator swears by the ‘Feel Good” folder. “I collect the nice things people have said about my work,” He explains. “It really helps re-reading them when I feel that my work is not ‘good enough’.” Similarly, creative manager Iftekhar Alam maintains “a small archive of projects, kind feedback, and milestones; it helps me see tangible progress when doubt creeps in.”
Juliana Salcedo is an illustrator and writer who believes that action, not rumination, is the way to go. “I’ve found that if I get into work, the joy of it lowers the imposter syndrome’s voice,” He says. “When I’m waiting for things to happen is when Adelfo—I’ve just named it— is at his worst.” In fact, naming the inner critic can help you to distance yourself from that feeling.
Are you struggling to start a new project because of the imposter’s syndrome? Lele Saa, an illustrator and designer, shares what she finds works. “I try to trick my brain to get into the work with a gentle activity,” She reveals. “So starting with research, I might go to a gallery or museum and sketch about what I need to illustrate. This helps me to generate ideas without overthinking, because I’ve already started.”
Analysis of the problem
Creatives have found that the best way for them to begin a new project is by removing emotion completely from the equation. Sandrine Bascouert, a photo retoucher who also creates creative artworks says that: “The only way I can get past my reluctance is by looking at hard facts. That means I’ll ask for a very detailed brief, ask tons of questions, and also run a timed test before I say yes.”
The Building a Brand Series on YouTube by The Futur gave Meredith Blumenfeld a new perspective. It showed her how professional designers work. “It was very important for me to see how all these talented designers didn’t get it 100% right on the first try, but that this can actually be a plus,” She says
Creative director PJ Richson has, in return, found an unanticipated ally in AI. “I use ChatGPT relentlessly to help me figure out how to structure my project, storyboards, areas to explore, schedules, and ideas if I don’t have any,” He explains. “The thinking being, that in spite of my over-thinking, doubtful, wandering mind in the face of discomfort, I just go back to the checklist when I get anxious.”
PJ combines a systematic approach to training with a mental motto he learned from observing ‘athletic visualisation videos’ on YouTube. “I tell myself in my head, ‘You are worthy, you are powerful, you are capable.’ It’s wild: it gives me this little boost of adrenaline I feel in my body.”
Community and Kindness: The Role of the Two
Many artists have emphasized the importance of community involvement in this. Richard for instance, emphasizes the importance of kindness. “We are in such a hyper-critical industry where people can be extremely judgmental,” He notes. “So if you see someone has put a lot of time and effort into a project and shared it with the world, be kind, because it’s probably taken them a lot to even share that piece of work.”
Yvie Junper-Johnson, an illustrator and author, also advocates for Self-help-compassion. “Imposter syndrome is, at the end of the day, an inherent desire to do the best you can and to raise your standards in an area that you respect, and where the standards are conceivably already high,” She points this out. “Remember to have grace for your own journey, which can never be compared to anyone else’s.”
Being kind to other people can also help you to be kind to yourself. As social media strategist and manager Jo Barber explains: “When I’m suffering imposter syndrome, I always think about what I’d say to someone else doubting themselves, such as ‘Who told you that?’. The answers usually reassure me after a few hours, which includes a TV show, food and sleep.”
Takeaways
What have we learned from this? Our community consensus suggests that, while uncomfortable, imposter’s syndrome doesn’t need to be crippling.
You can overcome doubt in many ways, whether you choose to build evidence for your own excellence, name your inner critic, focus on your service to others or simply remind yourself that we are all still learning. The conversation, and the willingness to share these feelings with others as well as strategies for overcoming them is what will most likely reduce the imposter’s syndrome.
You should consider that imposters are not usually concerned about their imposter status. Ironically, the fact that you feel an imposter proves your place in this world.