This seems to be an issue in the future. But isn’t that a cost of progress, too?
Common Sense Media released a report last week that found 72% of U.S. teenagers have used AI assistants, and many are now engaging in regular social interaction with the virtual friends they choose.
This study was based on an anonymous survey of 1 060 teens. It is not intended to be a comprehensive overview, but rather a measure of AI use. The trends are concerning, especially as some platforms look to add AI bots who can serve in a romantic capacity.
As noted above, 72% teens are regular AI bot users.
It’s important to note that AI bots haven’t reached the level they will likely reach in just a few years. Tech companies are investing billions into improving their AI bots, making them more human-like, conversational and more like real humans.
They’re not. Bots are able to respond to conversations based on context and weighting systems that each company uses in their process. They are not a simulation of human interaction and never will be due to their mental and physical connections.
We’re heading towards a time when this will be a viable alternative to civic engagement. What if the bot is changed? It could be infected by harmful code or hacked. ?
We do not know the broader mental health implications that may result from enabling and encouraging this type of connection.
We’re still moving forward, as 33% of teenagers already use AI for relationships and social interactions.
In some contexts, this can be a very beneficial thing.
The survey shows that 18% AI companions use the tools to get advice.
The benefits of nonjudgmental interactions are clear. 39% of AI users who have used bots to practice social skills have transferred these skills into real life situations. (Notably, this is more common among female users than males, with 45% doing so versus only 34%).
There will be benefits. Like social media, it’s a question of whether the positives outweigh the negatives.
In a survey, 31% of respondents said that AI-assisted conversations are as or even more enjoyable than conversations with human friends. 33% chose AI for some conversations.
The fact that AI bots are prone to “hallucinating” or making incorrect assumptions and then stating them as facts is also a cause for concern. This could potentially lead young people down the wrong road, leading to harm. The shift from AI to romantic partners raises even more concerns about relationships.
This seems to be a common use of AI, and it is inevitable that more people will want to have these understanding relationships, without judgment. Real people will never understand you like your algorithmically-aligned AI bot can, and that could actually end up exacerbating the loneliness epidemic, as opposed to addressing it, as some have suggested.
What does it mean for the future of young people’s concept of human connections, if they ever feel that they do need them?
They need it. Studies have been conducted for centuries that have highlighted the value of community and human connections, as well as the necessity of having real relationships in order to shape one’s understanding. Artificial intelligence bots can simulate a certain amount of this, but the importance of a physical connection, human proximity and real-world participation is just as important.
Over time we’ve been moving steadily away from it. You could even argue that the WHO declared severe loneliness a global threat.
Studies have found that loneliness increases the risk of dementia by 50% and incident heart disease or strokes by 30%.
Can AI bots assist in this? If not, then why do we push them so much? Why are all apps trying to get you to chat with non-existent entities and reveal your most intimate secrets?
What is more important, the AI model or big tech companies?
If you are inclined to the second conclusion, progress seems more important, as with the social media that preceded it. AI providers have already pushed for the European Union’s restrictions to be relaxed on AI. Meanwhile, the race to develop AI between countries is increasing pressure on governments around the world to ease up on their reigns.
Should we be encouraged or worried by the rapid spread of these powerful tools with serious impact elements?
There are many uses for AI that can increase productivity, creativity, opportunities, etc.
There are some areas where we need to tread with caution due to over-reliance and its effects on the whole.
In ten years, this will be seen from an entirely different angle.
Here is the report “Talk, Trust, and Trade-Offs”, by Common Sense Media.