This audio was automatically generated. If you have any feedback, please let us know.
It may seem that this is a small case and an example of EU overreach when it comes to policing platforms on social media. The Dutch court’s decision late last week that Meta must provide non-algorithmic options for feeds more readily accessible could have major implications and become an increasingly important focus of regulators.
Last Thursday, a Dutch court ruled that Meta has to provide Facebook and Instagram users with more easily accessible options for non-algorithm-defined timelines, in line with regulations outlined in the EU Digital Services Act (DSA).
According to the case brought forth by Bits of Freedom, a digital rights group, Meta has been acting in violation of Article 27, DSA which says that:
The terms of service for online platform providers that employ recommender systems must include in plain, understandable language the key parameters of their systems as well as the options available to the users of their services in order to change or modify those parameters. […] When there are multiple options for recommender system that decides the order in which information is presented to the recipients of the services, online platform providers shall provide a feature that allows them to choose and modify their preference at any given time.”
Under the DSA Meta and other large social platforms must share information about how they work, as well as allow their users to change their settings to customize their experience in app.
The DSA notes, in this particular case:
“That [selection and modification] “Functionality shall be easily and directly accessible in the section of the platform’s interface online where information is prioritized.”
The feeds that are being created by such algorithms must be “directly accessible and easy to use” in order to allow you to change what’s shown to you.
Meta offers a chronological time line in both of its apps. This was added in response to concerns raised by regulators about the user’s choice in various countries.
Meta is aware that the majority of people will not bother changing their default preference.
What Bits of Freedom claims work in Meta’s favor:
” Meta wants to steer users towards a feed that allows it to show the most interest and behavior-based advertisements possible. Meta’s core revenue model is based on this. The profiled feed has a subtle design that encourages users to click on it, while the feed without profiles is hidden by a logo and difficult to locate. Users that choose an alternative timeline lose access to direct messaging and other features. Meta is always the first feed that appears when the app opens, regardless of whether the user has previously selected another one. Meta’s behavior must be changed due to the ruling of the court. “
Meta has stated that they will appeal the ruling. If it is confirmed, Meta could be forced to let people opt-out of their algorithmic feed, reverting users back to an entirely chronological feed.
Meta does not believe that this will improve the user’s experience.
Adam Mosseri, Instagram’s chief, explained late last year that the non-algorithm news feeds no longer work, even though people think they do. The usage data that was gathered from their experiments showed the exact opposite.
As per Mosseri:
We’ve been tested [non-algorithm feeds] I’ve tried this a few times. Each time, we find a group of happy people, a few who don’t even remember they are in the survey, and overall everyone who is in the study uses Instagram less. When we asked them “how happy are you with Instagram?,” they reported being less satisfied with Instagram on average over time. Then there are these secondary effects, where friends stop using Instagram. [and] “It’s getting worse because people are using it less. They send fewer likes, comments and messages. And then, there is all this other stuff. It just keeps on getting worse.”
Meta wants to keep users in their apps longer and maximize engagement. They also want to gather valuable feedback from this. Algorithm feeds facilitate this better. According to Mosseri and from an business perspective, they are better. Meta does not want people to be able to opt out.
Algorithms have been identified by many as the main cause of division and angst. Their primary motivation is engagement.
What drives engagement? You can use algorithmic amplification to fuel fires of disagreement and opposition based on data that is derived from emotional responses. The strongest emotional drivers are fear, anger, and joy.
Frances Haugen was a former Facebook employee turned whistleblower who, as a result, launched various regulatory inquiries into the company. Her insight into Facebook’s operational approach and its lack of concern for the user impact led to the investigations.
Haugen argued that eliminating engagement-based rankings would reduce the divisions caused by social media applications, as it would limit the number of posts that arouse anger among the millions who use them daily. This would reduce the incentives for publishers to create such content to gain attention and impact the wider news ecosystem in a more balanced, measured way.
There is some logic in that. This wouldn’t completely eliminate such motivations (as the users could still share their posts and amplify them in any case). By reducing those factors that encourage angst, and division, it seems to be a natural evolution.
Mosseri noted that it could impact revenue for social apps as the usage of these applications would decline. Maybe it’s not worth the risk. If this Dutch ruling is upheld we might get to see how such feeds would impact certain markets, especially if Meta were forced to use non-algorithmic ones as defaults.
Meta will not volunteer to do such an experiment.
Meta now has two weeks from the Dutch court to provide users with a refund. “direct and simple” How to remove yourself from a recommended timeline (Meta is again appealing this verdict).