Last week, a designer asked a question in Creative Boom’s Instagram that I recognized instantly. The person had lost his or her job and went freelance as a matter of necessity.
Now, they are watching their projects dry up while everyone is talking about AI, layoffs, etc. “streamlining”. Their question was both simple and devasting: “Is this the end of my creative career?”
Freelancing is something I have done for about a decade. I’ve experienced slow times before. When I read the more than 40 responses, something was unsettling.
It’s not just another quiet February-January. Creative industries are experiencing something completely different. Pretending that business is as usual won’t help anyone.
It’s not slow season any more
“Honestly, it just feels bleak right now,” writes illustrator Louise Rosenkrands. “It doesn’t even feel like ‘slow season’ anymore.
More like the work just isn’t circulating at all.”
This sentiment is repeated throughout the thread. Lara Paulussen, the illustrator is more direct. “I don’t think this is still slow season: it feels more like a complete industry dying.”
Mike Williams is a graphic designer. This hasn’t happened over night. “Slow season has lasted 18 months for me,” He says. “Every project and studio wants a unicorn; all the job boards want three or four specialist roles filled by one.
It’s the same across many industries; a knock-on effect from global recessions impacting marketing budgets, filtering to studios and then freelancers.”
Luke Spicer, an illustrator from the UK tells a story similar to this. “I haven’t had a commission in at least 18 months and have given up, for now,” He says. “It was hard enough finding work five years ago. Now it feels almost entirely futile. If and when things ever improve—whether it’s the AI bubble bursting, the economy improving, or an increased demand for human-made art—I’ll give it another shot.
For now, I’m stuck in my unfulfilling part-time office job that barely pays the bills.”
This is not a group of panicky newcomers, or those who aren’t familiar with difficult markets. They are skilled creatives who have portfolios and many years of experience. All of them are saying that something has changed.
When you are facing a drought lasting a year-and-a half, the usual assurances regarding seasonal budgets or dips in spending don’t really ring true. It’s not about summer vacations or Christmas budgets. It’s true that the work isn’t being circulated as it once was.
It’s not selling out to do a side gig
The responses show that many creatives who have achieved success in their field are willing to take on additional work, and they do so without apologizing.
Alison Bick, a designer from London, has a story that is particularly moving. She took on a small heritage charity’s part-time administrative job ten years ago. “to tide over the hard times” While building up her design company.
“The charity now employs 20 people, and I became the designer about eight years ago,” She writes “I could never have imagined I’d now be doing my dream design job for the same organisation. And my dog comes to work too.”
Designer Jade Douglas also works weekends and evenings at a pub that sells board games to pay rent and other bills. “It’s definitely helped take the pressure off, and it’s also something interesting to talk about when I introduce myself to new potential clients.”
These stories are not a source of shame. There’s even relief. There is a myth. “real” Aspirations to be a creative who supports themselves solely through their art has never been as damaging as being able to support yourself.
Many of the most extraordinary artists in history also had day jobs. A designer with a second income source is not less talented; they are designers who pay their rent.
According to brand designer Chloe Marie Doyle: “We can tie so much of our sense of self to our work. Almost to the point where we can’t see ourselves doing anything else as a job. But it’s okay to look outside of our usual working perimeters when things are slow.”
There is work out there, (apparently).
Not everyone is depressed. Some designers have reported turning the situation around by making strategic changes.
Amy Goodall, a brand identity designer had a bad 2023.
She says that she then had a terrible 2023. “I started to really look objectively at my own brand and my marketing activity. I rebranded, repositioned myself, started marketing and changed up my messaging. So much of the right work is flowing to me now.”
Jackson Hallman, a graphic designer from Jackson Hallman: “The work is out there, the budgets are there, the people who want real designers and not just AI exist. But it’s not always easy to find them. You need to be creative in your approach.” Two years ago, for example, Courtney Flannagan, a designer, quit her job and went freelancing.
She used Pinterest as her primary platform. “I rarely pitch for work as Pinterest provides 90% of my clients,” She reports.
Takeaways
These success stories made me feel a mix of optimism and skepticism. Some people do thrive.
When the vast majority of respondents describe a drought lasting 18 months, it’s hard to say anything. “just market better” Feels inadequate. This is like saying to someone that they should bring an umbrella when there’s a storm.
What do we do in reality? Sincerity be damned, I have no neat solution.
It is a fact that the creative industries are changing at a rapid pace.
AI will not disappear. Budgets don’t expand by themselves. The gig economy is continuing to undervalue the creative workforce.
Here’s what I know after reading that thread, and my own personal experience.
-
It’s not your fault. If dozens of creatives with experience and talent are having trouble at the same time, then it is a systemic problem, not a personal one. Here are three main takeaways.
-
Everyone has a different idea of what survival means to them. Some will make a complete pivot. Some people will work part-time.
Others will increase their marketing efforts. All of these options are valid.
-
The community is important This thread’s most important part is not the advice, but the validation. It doesn’t make you rich, but knowing that you are not the only one struggling with this does help to reduce the feeling of failure.
-
The need for adaptation is unavoidable. The industry of five years ago will not return. This means that you need to learn new tools, find new revenue streams or completely redesign what it is that a creative job looks like.
Illustrator Connie Noble perhaps says it best. “It sucks right now, and everyone is scared—not just creatives—and it’s okay to be worried. Your career is not over because being a creative doesn’t leave you when work stops.”
She’s right.
She’s right. The identity does not. Maybe that is the difference we need to keep in mind as we try and figure out where we are going next.