You may feel that every moment of culture is now accompanied by a check-out button. The moment a film is released, there are limited edition sneakers, capsule collections, themed Airbnbs, beauty drops, and cocktail menus to match. No longer do we just read stories, but also shop for them.
The collaboration has become a powerful tool in marketing today. As they grow, we should ask a deeper question: Are they creating brands or are they just making noise?
Suzanne Powers, co-founder and partner of Tracksuit Agency, and strategic advisory firm All& explains. “When two brands come together – and we think of brands loosely as everything from companies that make products to human brands like creators – there’s this moment where you think, ‘I’m not sure these two things go together?’ But when it works, the impact is exponential for both sides.”
Barbie’s blueprint
Barbie in 2023 is a great example.
It wasn’t only the film that dominated box offices. The film dominated social media feeds, shelves and wardrobes. It was a cultural masterclass, from Barbiecore fashion and beauty partnerships to travel experiences.
The scale was part of the spectacle. It worked. The film was a worldwide event thanks to the commercial eco-system.
Compare that to Margot Robbie’s new project Wuthering Heights. The gothic classic of obsession, tragedy, and restraint is not a scream.
“merch opportunity”. We are here.
Fashion tie-ins. Branded experience.
Candles with scents that evoke the Moors.
Barbie – splitov27 – stock.adobe.com
The collaboration economy is attracting stories that are rooted in austerity.
These partnerships can be clever. Aspinal of London’s leather item, which scored a high score of 86 in Tracksuit Collab Index, a tool used to measure collaborations that add value as opposed to those that are just hype, reflects themes of ambition, desire, and class. A high-end, indulgent tie-in with food reflects the lifestyle of Linton’s household.
Collaborations are used as signals in these situations. Meaning is shaped by collaborations. The story is expanded by them.
Here’s where the tension is. The majority of collaborations don’t last.
These collaborations are designed to make a statement. Moments are important. Moments matter. Conversations are triggered. Brands gain cultural relevance through them in real-time.
They may be enjoyed by consumers while live.
They also tend to move quickly.
It’s not exhaustion of the consumer that is the risk. It’s confusion.
It’s confusion.
Marketing theatre vs strategic partnerships
Simple tests can help separate them.
Would your brand have been significantly weaker in five years if this partnership never occurred?
The honest answer to this question is usually no. This doesn’t mean they are pointless. They are just tactical.
They are designed to achieve something structural. New audiences are opened up. Positioning is reinforced. Innovation is a result. Over time, they compound.
By contrast, marketing theatre is designed for the present.
This is optimized for attention, headlines and social media engagement. This can work.
It rarely alters a brand’s trajectory over the long term.
We have seen at Tracksuit that clarity and consistency are the keys to sustained awareness, consideration, and preference. Collaborations are a great way to amplify this strategy. Rarely do they replace the original strategy.
Reach out and Resonance
Another shift is also happening.
Brands that are successful at collaboration don’t try to work with everybody. The brands that are successful at collaboration don’t chase scale just for its own sake.
The partnerships they choose are more natural than opportunistic.
The research that we did with Bimma William revealed a clear theme: most successful collaborations are those which deepen the connection to small passionate communities. The focus is on resonance rather than reach.
True influence doesn’t mean being everywhere.
It’s more about showing up with intention in the right place.
The power of collaboration is not diminishing. Its power, however, is sometimes overstated.
Collaboration loses its distinctiveness when every moment of culture becomes an opportunity for commercial gain. This becomes the norm. It is rare that default builds brand equity over the long term.
Brands that win will not be the ones who collaborate most.
The brands that will win aren’t the most collaborative.
The best thing to do is not always ask. “Who can we partner with?”
It’s asking, “Does this make our brand stronger in the long run?”
Haworth, Yorkshire. Images licensed through Alamy