Food safety hazards in the modern food production process – Summary
- Early food safety concerns can persist and emerge through the processing
- After microbes have been completely removed, heat-stable toxins may still survive
- The safety of new technologies and products is unknown and complicated.
- Risk assessments are detailed and identify real microbial threats as well as toxin pathways
- Tests to verify mitigation strategies in real-world conditions
The safety of food is paramount. Anybody in the food industry will confirm this.
If there is a lesson that can be learned from the recent case of cereulide being found in infant formula, it would be to remember that food safety risks are not always apparent.
Food safety can be affected by new ingredients or processing conditions. Pathogens can be found everywhere, and many produce toxic substances that outlive the organisms they are produced by.
It is important to conduct a thorough risk analysis to determine which risks are pertinent and to know what the manufacturers should be monitoring in their production.
Recent headlines around the world have been made about the recall of baby formula that was contaminated by cereulide.
Cereulide can be produced by certain strains Bacillus cereus. B. cereus was not present in the formulation.
It is more likely that bacteria produced toxin early on in the manufacturing chain, and then were eliminated during downstream processing. The toxin, however, was transferred and because it is highly heat-stable, wouldn’t be destroyed by subsequent heat treatments.
Microbes are not the only ones to be concerned about.
It is a good example of how complicated food safety has become. B. cereus, like many other potentially pathogenic bacteria, can be found in almost any environment, including raw materials, soil and food production plants. As in the case of cereulide, even though the bacteria may have been long-gone, their toxins can remain.
It is obvious that the test should be performed to determine the presence of both the toxin and the microorganism. The cereulide problem is a challenging one.
B. cereus is not expected to grow on formula powders or their ingredients. Testing for cereulide, therefore, would be a difficult task.
There are also many microorganisms, such as Bacillus, Staphylococcus, and Clostridium, that produce toxins that remain stable at high temperatures. Not to mention the mycotoxins produced by numerous fungi. It would be costly, if it were not impossible to test for every possible toxin.
Food safety threats from new production techniques
Recent trends in the food industry have exacerbated this challenge.
Food safety is changing due to precision fermentation, biomass-based processing and circular ingredients streams. Fermentation based on fungi often needs temperatures and pH levels which could encourage Bacillus species. Even small contaminations can lead to rapid growth of microorganisms on high-nutrient substrates. Minor changes to temperature, pH and processing time can tip the process in favor of unwanted microorganisms.
How can manufacturers of food and ingredients maintain the safety of their products? Before production starts, carry out an in-depth food safety assessment.
Food safety: Assessing real risk
This means mapping each step of (planned) production – starting with raw materials, fermentation conditions and ending up in downstream processing and storage.
It is important to know which microbes pose a real threat, whether they can grow in certain environments and produce toxic substances, and if those substances could make it into the final product.
This assessment requires a multidisciplinary approach. This requires a deep understanding of the behaviours of specific organisms.
As an example, the growth rate of B. cereus at low temperature and toxin production of different strains varies dramatically.
Understanding the processing techniques is also important, including those that are used once microbes have been removed from production streams. The way an ingredient was produced, for example, could have a direct impact on whether or not toxins are passed along to the next generation.
Modeling tools can be invaluable in this case. Modeling tools are invaluable in this case. It allows for a complete assessment of the risks involved and helps to avoid unpleasant surprises during production.
Data-driven mitigation
An in-depth risk assessment identifies the critical points and hazards in the production cycle where the conditions can tip towards unwanted growth of microorganisms or toxic production. Companies can then implement appropriate monitoring and controls to avoid it or change downstream processing methods (such as membrane filtering or extraction) to keep toxins from reaching the end product.
Verification is often an overlooked step
The best method to determine potential threats and create mitigation strategies is through model-based assessments. Verifying the results is the next step, which is often overlooked.
It is possible to do this by simulating production setups in the laboratory and using appropriate microbial species to monitor growth, toxins production, and toxin passage through the process. Verification gives manufacturers the confidence to know that mitigation and control measures work in real-life conditions.
Understanding where risk originates
Food safety in the modern world is more complex than simply keeping bacteria out. The manufacturers must understand the behavior of microbes across all processes, and they should be aware that toxin can persist long after organisms have been removed.
Risks are continually changing due to new ingredients, technologies, and production methods. Thorough, scientifically-based assessments of risk can identify weak points and determine whether the controls are robust. It was a rare case, but the infant formula scandal highlighted an important truth. The threats we should be looking for are usually the ones that we overlook.