When a Roth IRA with a custodial Roth IRA is the best option, and when another savings account may make more sense
When you start a college savings fund for your children, it is often necessary to sort through different financial accounts. Each account has its own rules and benefits.
Many families are focused on 529 plans. However, others wonder if a Roth IRA can also be used to save for education.
The idea of Roth IRAs sounds good at first because they allow for money to grow without tax. Custodial Roth IRAs were designed primarily for retirement planning, and not to fund education.
As a result, it is often not advisable to use a Roth IRA for education expenses. Knowing the differences will help you select a savings strategy for your child that is most beneficial.
Why aren’t custodial Roth IRAs suitable for college savings?
Custodial Roth IRAs are not designed to be used for college savings. They offer long-term benefits but they’re really more suited to retirement planning. These are the main limitations that prevent you from using custodial Roth IRAs as a college saving account.
- The Roth IRAs are designed for retirement saving: They’re a type of retirement account.
Their benefits are greatest when the money is invested over the long term. If you withdraw money earlier to pay for college, it would limit the compounding growth over decades that retirement funds are intended to offer.
- Child must earn income.
Another important limitation is the requirement that a Roth IRA custodial account be opened and funded by a child who has earned an income. These accounts are not ideal for college saving, particularly when the child is too young to have an income.
- The annual contribution limit can be a barrier to growth. Even if a kid earns an income, Roth IRAs are still subjected to the limits. This can slow down the accumulation of funds compared to accounts that are geared towards education and allow much larger contributions.
- Roth IRA withdrawal rules are complicated.
Contributions are generally tax- and penalty-free. However, if you withdraw earnings prior to retirement age there may be taxes or penalties.
Custodial Roth-IRAs can be great tools for saving, but they aren’t the best option to save money on education.
You can also save for college by using other options
Custodial Roth IRAs were designed primarily for retirement. Many families now turn to alternative types of accounts which are more suited to supporting education costs. Your financial goals will determine the best option for you. You’ll also want to consider how flexible you would like the money used and what level of control over your account you are comfortable with.
When planning to send their children to college, many families consider several options for saving money.
Plan 529
The 529 Plan is the most popular education saving account because it helps families to save money for educational costs.
The plans allow for tax-deferred growth of investments and tax-free withdrawals if used to pay qualified educational expenses.
Many families choose a 529 Plan to create a college fund.
Coverdell Education Savings accounts
Coverdell Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) are another account that offers tax advantages for educational expenses.
As with a 529 Plan, withdrawals are tax free when they’re used to pay for eligible education expenses. Coverdell ESAs have lower contributions limits, and there are income restrictions.
UGMA Accounts
A UGMA Account allows grandparents or parents to invest funds for their children until they reach the age of majority.
The accounts allow families to accumulate savings by investing in stocks, mutual funds and bonds.
Unlike Roth IRAs, UGMAs do not require that the child has earned an income. This makes them more accessible to those who want to save money for their younger children.
The money is not limited to education costs.
It can be spent on anything that will benefit the child.
Custodial Roth IRAs are a great way to start a child’s long-term savings for retirement. These accounts, which are primarily designed for retirement, have limitations and may not be the best option for saving money for college.
Families who are primarily focused on funding education can benefit from accounts such as 529 Plans, UGMA Accounts, and Coverdell ESAs.