4 chocolate subscription clubs that make great gifts

4 Chocolate Subscription Clubs That Make Great Gifts

Chocolate subscription boxes, sold as chocolate clubs, are probably the most popular of all the food clubs, especially for gifting. The editors at Taste of Home tested five of the most popular services to find out which earn their monthly fee and which make you want to click unsubscribe.

The winner was the Compartes Chocolate of the Month Club. February’s box arrived with two bars and a heart-shaped assortment of chocolates spelling out I Love You, and the strawberry cream and creme brulee pieces drew particular praise. Each bar retails for $9.95, putting the value of a $75 monthly box near $95, and the club ships with a no-melt guarantee. The catch is a minimum of three deliveries, or $180, which makes it better suited to gifting across a run of occasions than to a one-off treat.

Dandelion Chocolate took second place for connoisseurs. Its $75 monthly box holds six bars, two each from three single origins, and the two-ingredient blend puts the cocoa itself front and center. The tester called it the most impressive presentation she had seen across more than 30 food subscriptions, with origin maps and tasting instructions in the box. Milk chocolate fans should look elsewhere.

Harry & David won the value case at around $50 a shipment. Its club sends 32 chocolates and truffles, from salted caramel cups to milk chocolate cremes, in a style designed to please rather than provoke. The tester said the delivery was worth the company’s reputation. The limits are high shipping costs without a Celebrations Passport and no proper gift option, since members have to cancel manually.

Formaggio Kitchen’s bean-to-bar club came in for people who want to learn about makers. Three bars arrive each month, large, medium and small, with a QR code linking to background on the selection. Quality was high at around $75, but one bar arrived broken and the quantity stayed modest, so the club suits devotees more than casual cocoa fans.

Megan Giller, founder of Chocolate Noise, said buyers should look for clubs that work directly with cocoa farmers or pay fair trade premiums, and should match the number of makers and the delivery schedule against their own appetite, because too little or too much chocolate is equally disappointing.

Gourmet Chocolate Club failed the test, with chocolates that tasted dull and stale for close to $75, and Hotel Chocolat stays on the list to test. The full rankings sit in the original Taste of Home review.

For background on why everyone is chasing cocoa right now, see why chocolate sales are booming and why Hershey is going back to real chocolate.

Share Article
Facebook
LinkedIn
X
Harley Street-trained psychotherapist moves his practice to Poland to treat British expats online
DoorDash to buy Instacart in $17bn deal, its largest takeover to date
Hundreds of GP practices lose online services as provider Silicon Practice collapses
Secret Link