Four Best Book Subscriptions Tested By Bibliophiles (19459000)
Contributor (4)
Contributor (4)
Published on Aug. 22, 2025
Our editors were impressed by only six of the options we tried.
Every product that we showcase is hand-picked by our editors and expert reviewers. Your purchases may result in us earning a commission.
Learn more.
The best book subscriptions are the perfect gift for avid readers. Book clubs can be a great gift for friends and family. They not only provide new titles to bibliophiles, but also offer other goodies such as hot drinks, candles, and fun trinkets.
We tested six services and found the most suitable options for each type of reader.
The Best of the Overall
Book of the Month Club
Continue reading
Use Best Practice
Used Books Monthly
Continue reading
Classics at their Best
Bookishly Coffee & Book Club
Continue reading
The Best Care Package
Bookstores & More
Continue reading
The FAQ
What is the cost of a Book of the Month subscription?
Continue reading
KATIE BANDURSKI for TASTE of HOME
Pros:
-
You can rely on high-quality books
-
New and established authors in a mix
-
Choose between audiobook or hardcover
-
5-7 selections per month
-
Variety of genres, plots and characters
-
Free shipping for all orders
-
Cancel or pause easily
Cons:
-
The book selections are skew towards female readers
-
All picks for all members are identical
Book of the Month Club is the top-rated book subscription out of the many services that we have tested. After creating an online account, users are presented with a list of all the hardcovers and audiobooks for that month. Members follow a formula each month by selecting from five to seven new releases that are curated. The books are only $17.99 each with free shipping. This is one of the most budget-friendly options that we have tried.
If you are a voracious reader who is always on the lookout for the latest releases, the Book of the Month Club will not disappoint. It’s like getting a preview from a friend who is well read. You can find out more about it here. Katie Bandurski, Deputy editor of Book of the Month Review says: “We send you the top new titles every month and their best recommendations.”
KATIE BANDURSKI for TASTE of HOME
Katie first tested Book of the Month Club in 2024 for three months – July, August, and September. She retested the service a little over a year after, in July, August and May 2025, to ensure it held up. She’s been impressed by the service each time. She and two other editors gifted the service to family and friends, which was always well received.
Katie says, “Another cool thing about Book of the Month Club titles is they’re not the same hardback trade books that you can buy at Barnes & Noble.” Each dust jacket includes the Book of the Month Logo, along with the embellishment of the month and the year. All the books have a standard format, making it easy to display them on your shelves.
Book of the Month Club makes a great gift, whether it’s for your family or friends. It’s also a good way to save if you are an avid reader. Katie points out that, as of publication, all of these books, including her favourite, “Husbands & Lover” by Beatriz William, cost less than what Barnes & Noble was asking for. You can also find out more about the following: Amazon.
Taste of Home with EMILY Way
Pros:
-
Cheap
-
Old books are given new life
-
There are many genres to choose from
-
Book genres that match your choice
-
Choose between two or four titles per month
Cons:
-
These titles aren’t new releases
-
The books may be visibly worn out.
-
Packaging that is less than impressive
CrateJoy offers many of the food subscription boxes we love. The website offers a variety of gift-of-the month clubs including my favorite: Used Books Monthly. The titles of this book club are older than other clubs. They are older titles I may not have noticed, but it’s fun to discover new authors.
Subscribers receive two to four gently used titles that correspond with their favorite genre each month. Genres include historical, fantasy and science-fiction. A handy textbox is available at checkout. Customers can add notes on their favourite authors, or specific details about the genres they choose. I was most impressed by “Amped”, a philosophical science fiction book from an unknown author, which Daniel H. Wilson wrote.
Taste of Home with EMILY Way
This is an affordable service, costing between $8 and $16 per book. The packaging, which is a manila envelope standard in size, is not fancy. This may make it difficult to gift. The books were packaged well and only minor damage was found on arrival. Used Books Monthly has clearly vetted each book to make sure it meets its quality standards.
This isn’t the kind of book club where you get new books and fancy add-ons. But it does a great job at bringing new life to older titles. The books that I got were all in my chosen genres, and I was introduced to authors and titles I would never have heard about otherwise. This is an excellent option for someone who enjoys getting a surprise every month.
Taste of Home with EMILY Way
Pros:
-
Classics in all their forms
-
Wrapping books in Gift Paper
-
Includes locally roasted coffee
-
Most books have a customized dust jacket
Cons:
-
Branding and Quality Inconsistent
-
The shipping from the UK can be expensive
Bookishly’s Book Club will appeal to those who enjoy brewing a cup of hot coffee or espresso while reading a literary classic. Every month, a literary classic is offered along with freshly-roasted espresso or coffee beans. Shipping is more expensive than normal because this service comes from U.K. The subscription is still relatively cheap at $17.55 per monthly.
Mary Henn, editor of the magazine “Five Children and It”, was particularly impressed by the care taken in packaging her books. Unboxing feels like opening a present, which adds to the excitement.
Taste of Home with EMILY Way
The first two packages were delivered as promised, with a literary classic paperback and Bookishly’s exclusive dust jacket. They also included a bookmark that matched the design on the dust jacket. The dust jackets and bookmarks were also adorned with PERKuLATTE and a card that matched the book’s design.
The second box was not the same. Mary was surprised to receive a vintage book instead of the new one with the custom dust jacket, and a matching synopsis. She appreciates that vintage books were included, but she is also pleased because vintage books weren’t in the description of the club. Mary still enjoyed this service, and she would recommend it for those who enjoy classic literature.
There’s a Tea and Classics option for those who would rather drink tea than coffee.
KATIE BANDURSKI for TASTE of HOME
Pros:
-
A great selection of books with fun accessories
-
Giftable packaging
-
New releases by popular authors
-
You can customize your own product
-
Value for money
Cons:
-
Subscriptions are more expensive than others
Books & More is the perfect option for those looking to get a book subscription and a care package in one. The focus is not solely on literature, as it was with the other companies listed. Every monthly package includes a selection of one or two titles, as well as a variety of other goodies. Katie Bandurski, Deputy Editor at the magazine’s website says that it feels as if you receive a monthly gift.
She received a brand new paperback and a ton of extra goodies in her box. Included are small items such as tea bags, stickers and earrings to bigger ones like gratitude journals and lotion. The books were not all brand-new, but they were still relatively recent. Katie’s selections were skewed toward female readers and ranged between 2016-2023. She chose “One True Loves”, by Taylor Jenkins Reid. This is an author that she already knows.
KATIE BANDURSKI for TASTE of HOME
For the price I believe you are getting a good deal. It’s a great value. Katie says, “I honestly believed the boxes improved over time with bigger and more add-ons.” You can customize the box to suit your tastes, but I didn’t do that.
You can customize your subscription by swapping out the extras with an extra book or switching between bonus or extra books every month. It’s more expensive than most subscriptions, at $44.99 for one book per month. However, it is worth it because of the added bonuses. This is a great choice for gifting. You can also find out more about the following: Self-care is important, particularly for readers who like to explore current authors.
What to look for when buying a book subscription
There are several things to consider when shopping for a new book club. The price is the first consideration, and for most customers it’s also their top priority. Others prefer saving money on books, while some don’t care if they spend a bit more on services. The price of book clubs can vary from $10 per month to $200. Before shopping, we recommend setting a budget.
Like a tea-club, you should also consider your personal tastes. Some readers prefer to customize their experience by choosing titles themselves, like in the Book of the Month Club. Others don’t care and even enjoy a surprise element. We encourage our readers to pick a service which allows them to choose their preferred genres. You can also choose a monthly service like Book of the Month Club that allows you to pause the subscription each month.
It’s also important to consider the number of titles you would like to receive each month. Book of the Month Clubs can offer you a monthly read or a selection. Consider how many books you will read before you receive the next shipment.
Decide if you want to read older books or only new ones. A budget-friendly service such as Used Book Club is perfect for those who aren’t concerned about receiving outdated books. For those who prefer the latest in literary works, they should be prepared to spend a little more.
Consider whether or not you would like to receive additional bonuses, such as gourmet tea, candles, and other goodies. Some book clubs offer only the books, while others include a variety of other goodies. They are great for self-care and as gifts to readers.
What We found the best book subscription boxes
We first collected four editors with different genre preferences and who enjoy reading. We then researched the top book clubs. We narrowed our list down to the six most popular book of the month services after reading hundreds of reviews.
We each purchased at least one three-month subscription and recorded our experiences. The entire process was documented, including the order, the customization, the cost-value ratio, the genre match, the packaging, and the extras. After compiling our notes, we compared services and chose to only review those that were truly enjoyable.
The Other Subscriptions we Tested
BookBrews: Each box included a chocolatey sweet treat, as well as either coffee or tea depending on what the customer chose. Our editor also picked the right books for each genre. We didn’t like that the beans came in drawstring bags with breathable material. For added freshness, we’d prefer a bag which was airtight. The price was also high.
Plot Twist Parcels: This subscription is not recommended. This subscription is not recommended. It’s a real disappointment because there were other inclusions like tea, lotion and booklights. Although the price may seem low, what you get is worth it.
The FAQ
What is the cost of a Book of the Month subscription?
The price of a Book of the Month subscription varies. Prices vary depending on the number of books, whether or not they are brand new and if there are any extras. The cpst for a book-of-the month club can range from $10 to as much as $200. Most clubs average around $20.
Book subscription boxes: Are they worth the money?
A book subscription box will be a great gift for those who love to read and love surprises. These boxes make wonderful gifts, especially for those who love to read. They are also great for birthdays or holidays.
We Are Trustworthy
We could call ourselves professional connoisseurs of gift of the Month Club. Enjoy the Taste of Home We’ve been to more monthly clubs than we can count, including coffee clubs, puzzle clubs and flower subscriptions. We are avid readers and book enthusiasts in our free time. We explored different genres to determine the worth of these clubs. Each club was also bought for three months to allow us to compare the different shipping experiences.